Free Shipping Versus Fast Shipping. Which is Better for eCommerce Order Fulfillment?

 In eCommerce, Fulfillment, Shipping, Subscription eCommerce, Supply Chain


The choice between offering free shipping and fast shipping in eCommerce order fulfillment depends on various factors, including your business model, target audience, and product offerings. Both options have their advantages and potential drawbacks, and the decision should align with your specific goals and customer expectations.


Let’s Explore the Pros and Cons of Free Shipping and Fast Shipping.


Advantages of Free Shipping:

Attractive to Customers:

Free shipping is a highly appealing offer for eCommerce order fulfillment customers. It eliminates the uncertainty of additional costs and can be a significant factor in their decision to complete a purchase.

Competitive Advantage:

In a competitive e-commerce landscape, offering free shipping can be a powerful differentiator. Many customers actively seek out businesses that provide this benefit, making it a key selling point.

Increased Average Order Value:

To meet the minimum purchase requirements for free shipping, customers often add more items to their cart. This upselling tactic increases the average order value and boosts revenue.

Customer Loyalty:

Providing free shipping can lead to higher levels of customer satisfaction. Satisfied customers are more likely to become repeat customers and refer your business to others, contributing to long-term customer loyalty.

Related: 4 Benefits of a Streamlined eCommerce Supply Chain.


Challenges of Free Shipping:

Shipping Costs:

Offering free shipping comes at a cost to eCommerce order fulfillment businesses. You typically absorb the shipping expenses, which can impact your profit margins. It’s crucial to assess whether your pricing structure can accommodate these costs.

Setting Minimums:

To offset the costs of free shipping, businesses often set minimum purchase requirements for customers to qualify. However, this can deter some potential customers who don’t meet the threshold or prefer to make smaller purchases.

Delivery Time:

Free shipping often involves standard delivery times, which may be slower than expedited options. This could lead to longer delivery times, potentially frustrating customers who seek quick order fulfillment.

Related: What is Order Fulfillment and How Does it Work?


Advantages of Fast Shipping:

Competitive Edge:

Fast shipping provides a competitive edge, especially in industries where rapid delivery is a customer priority. It positions your business as a leader in terms of customer service.

Customer Convenience:

Quick shipping caters to customers who desire immediate gratification. This convenience can be a significant selling point, particularly for products where speed is essential.

Lower Cart Abandonment:

Shortened delivery times reduce cart abandonment rates. Customers are less likely to change their minds or explore other options during the purchase process if they know they’ll receive their items quickly.

Premium Pricing:

You have the option to charge a premium for expedited shipping services. This can help offset the higher costs associated with fast shipping and potentially improve your profit margins.

Related: Techniques for Better Inventory Management.


Challenges of Fast Shipping:

Higher Costs:

Offering fast shipping is generally more expensive than standard or free shipping. Costs may include expedited transportation, specialized packaging, and logistics management. These costs may be passed on to customers, potentially affecting price competitiveness.

Logistics Complexity:

Coordinating quick delivery times requires a well-organized logistics system. This includes efficient inventory management, order processing, and carrier partnerships. Setting up and maintaining such a system can be complex and costly. This is where a 3PL like Elite OPS can help.

Customer Expectations:

Once you introduce fast shipping as an option, customers may come to expect it as the norm. This can make it challenging to transition back to standard delivery if circumstances change.

Related: How Can a 3PL Cut Operational Costs for eCommerce Businesses?



Free shipping versus fast shipping. Which is better for eCommerce order fulfillment

How to Choose Between Free and Fast Shipping:

Your decision between free and fast shipping should be influenced by several factors:

Product Type:

Consider the nature of your products. Some items, such as perishable goods or urgent replacements, may naturally lend themselves to fast shipping. For others, especially non-essential items, free shipping may be sufficient and might be a better option.

Customer Base:

Understanding your target audience is crucial. Different customer segments may have varying expectations. Conduct surveys, analyze data, and obtain customer feedback to determine what matters most to your eCommerce order fulfillment customers.

Competitive Landscape:

Evaluate your competitors and market trends. If your competitors offer free shipping as a standard, you might consider fast shipping as a competitive edge, especially if it aligns with your brand and customer expectations.

Profit Margins:

Examine your business’s financial health and profit margins. Can you absorb the costs of free shipping, or do you need to charge for shipping to maintain profitability? It’s essential to strike a balance between customer benefits and business viability.

Seasonal Variations:

Consider how seasonal variations, such as holidays or peak shopping seasons, might impact your shipping strategy. During these times, customers often expect faster shipping, and it’s essential to be prepared to meet those demands.

Testing and Optimization:

Many e-commerce businesses experiment with different shipping options to understand customer responses better. You can adjust your strategy based on the results of A/B testing and customer feedback, finding the right balance between free and fast shipping options.

Related: How to Offer Fast & Affordable Shipping for eCommerce.


Bottom Line

In practice, many businesses use a combination of both strategies. For example, they may offer free shipping with standard delivery times as a standard option and provide fast shipping as a premium choice for those willing to pay extra. This provides flexibility while catering to a broad customer base with varying needs and preferences. Ultimately, your shipping strategy should align with your brand, business goals, and the needs and expectations of your customers.



An external fulfillment service partner like Elite OPS is responsible for picking, packing, and shipping orders. Consider such a strategy to reduce shipping and operational costs.

Elite OPS has been a leader in Shipping and Logistics for over 25 years. Contact Us to find out how we can help you Save Time and Money on Procurement as a Service, eCommerce Order Fulfillment, and Kitting and Assembly.

Call 855-553-5490 or Click Here to Request a Quote!













Recommended Posts
Contact Us

We're not around right now. But you can send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

Not readable? Change text. captcha txt

Call Now

Same-Day Shipping Secrets: How to Meet Customer Expectations.Christmas is Almost Here! Here are 5 Tips to Boost eCommerce Sales.